• About
  • Our Team
  • Contact Us
Saturday, April 1, 2023
Falcons
  • Home
  • The Cases
  • Insight
  • In the Press
No Result
View All Result
  • Home
  • The Cases
  • Insight
  • In the Press
No Result
View All Result
No Result
View All Result

Home » Daily Maverick’s pyrrhic court ‘Victory’ won’t wash off the CIA stain against it

Daily Maverick’s pyrrhic court ‘Victory’ won’t wash off the CIA stain against it

by Opinion
August 16, 2022
in Insight
Daily Maverick’s pyrrhic court ‘Victory’ won’t wash off the CIA stain against it

READ ALSO

ANC KwaZulu-Natal displays political intolerance

RIGHT OF REPLY: The IRR will not forsake its classical liberal values


OPINION: The Daily Maverick’s pyrrhic victory was not on merit. A large, well-funded organisation simply bullied a young student who was vulnerable and exposed.

Jamie Roz

ON August 15, the South Gauteng High Court passed a default judgment against a Unisa student, Modibe Modiba, concerning tweets that exposed Branislav “Branko” Brkic’s Daily Maverick.

Coincidentally, the court judgment comes a week after an explosive exposé against Daily Maverick, among other media houses. The Daily Maverick and some local media houses were exposed as a nexus of media houses funded by the United States’ Central Intelligence Agency (CIA) through the State Department-linked non-governmental organisations (NGOs).

The Daily Maverick never refuted Ajit Sing and Roscoe Palm’s exposé titled “Manufacturing consent: How the United States has penetrated South African media”. The extensive search article is published on the MR Online.org website.

Coming back to the judgment and the pyrrhic “victory” of the Daily Maverick, the judgment timing is meant to deflect from the exposé. The judgment is clear that it was not on merit. A large, well-funded organisation simply bullied a young student who was vulnerable and exposed.

When analysing the developments of the time of the alleged tweets by Modiba, it is extremely difficult to make sense of why Modiba would have singled out the Daily Maverick for those tweets. Furthermore, Modiba also exposed that they were paid to attack those specific individuals.

Modiba’s claims are not far-fetched, especially when you conduct a Google search on “Astroturfing and the CIA”. The shocking results reveal the underbelly of media and social media manipulation by the CIA. But the methods would not be out of reach for the Daily Maverick.

A 2011 Guardian article talks about even more advanced methods in the report titled “Revealed: US spy operation that manipulates social media”.

Some Twitter spats here in South Africa uncovered how most of the “Black Twitter” micro-influencers were part of groups covertly hired by companies to do promos. But the downside has been instances where the same social media was weaponised against competing brands and individuals.

Many of us know and see what Modiba spoke about daily. But it is too expensive to speak the truth against institutions with money and power. However, the exposé threatens the veil of credibility that sustains the existence of organisations such as the Daily Maverick.

Without the entire case sitting, what we would know would be the R100 000 default judgment. The public was denied the opportunity to know the truth.

Over a year after Modiba’s exposé of the Daily Maverick, an expert report using big data from Twitter corroborated his claims. In an article by investigative journalists Sizwe Dlamini and Sihle Makhowana, titled “Bell Pottinger 2.0: Targeting Survé & Sekunjalo”, the Daily Maverick featured prominently.

The most telling conclusion by Dlamini and Makhowana is that “… data analysis showed that accounts associated with @News24 and @amaBhungane and @dailymaverick were all retweeted in a synchronous way with the support of bots.” But it did not end there.

Immediately when the Independent Media released the article, Jean Le Roux, a Daily Maverick-regular data journalist for DFR Lab, sprung into action, rubbishing the findings without providing evidence.

A few months later, the Daily Maverick released an article riddled with inaccuracies by Le Roux. The article titled “Paid influencers and sock puppets drove social media campaign targeting SA banks that cut ties with Iqbal Survé’s Sekunjalo” was a propaganda attack against Dr Survé – again corroborating claims by Modiba.

Interestingly, DFR Labs is a programme under the Atlantic Council, a US and North Atlantic Treaty Organisation (Nato) linked organisation.

While the Daily Maverick may be celebrating its victory against the unresourced student, raw and open source data points to the same conclusion of the claims by Modiba.

Sharp as it may be, the timing of the delivery of the judgment favouring Daily Maverick will not wash off the unchallenged CIA stain and facts against it.

Jamie Roz is an independent writer. The views expressed here are his own.


ShareTweet

Related Posts

ANC KwaZulu-Natal displays political intolerance
corruption

ANC KwaZulu-Natal displays political intolerance

February 15, 2023
RIGHT OF REPLY: The IRR will not forsake its classical liberal values
Insight

RIGHT OF REPLY: The IRR will not forsake its classical liberal values

August 18, 2022
Why does the media seem to support Ramaphosa and not demand answers from him?
Insight

Why does the media seem to support Ramaphosa and not demand answers from him?

August 17, 2022
Amazemtiti: The making of a native bourgeoisie class in colonial South Africa
Insight

Amazemtiti: The making of a native bourgeoisie class in colonial South Africa

August 16, 2022
Unclaimed Benefits: Is the retirement fund industry doing enough?
Insight

Unclaimed Benefits: Is the retirement fund industry doing enough?

August 11, 2022
Are we seeing a case of the paid piper with IRR’s Daily Friend?
Insight

Are we seeing a case of the paid piper with IRR’s Daily Friend?

August 10, 2022
Next Post
Amazemtiti: The making of a native bourgeoisie class in colonial South Africa

Amazemtiti: The making of a native bourgeoisie class in colonial South Africa

EDITOR'S PICK

Is KZN the factory of hitmen?

Is KZN the factory of hitmen?

March 8, 2023
ANC KwaZulu-Natal displays political intolerance

ANC KwaZulu-Natal displays political intolerance

February 15, 2023
Nepad concerned about South Africa’s energy crisis

Nepad concerned about South Africa’s energy crisis

February 9, 2023
ANC’s 30-year rule marked by empty promises and rhetoric

ANC’s 30-year rule marked by empty promises and rhetoric

January 23, 2023

POPULAR NEWS

Presidency reveals progress made to curb energy crisis engulfing SA

Presidency reveals progress made to curb energy crisis engulfing SA

January 23, 2023
Cyril Ramaphosa broke the law – Phala Phala Farmgate report

Cyril Ramaphosa broke the law – Phala Phala Farmgate report

December 1, 2022
Bawa accused of obstructing the course of justice

Bawa accused of obstructing the course of justice

October 27, 2022
Banks’ failure to adhere to FATF guidelines poses a major risk for SA economy

Banks’ failure to adhere to FATF guidelines poses a major risk for SA economy

August 25, 2022
RIGHT OF REPLY: The IRR will not forsake its classical liberal values

RIGHT OF REPLY: The IRR will not forsake its classical liberal values

August 18, 2022

About

The Falcons mission is to provide quality in-depth reporting on matters that would otherwise not be covered by mainstream media, to equip the public with factual information that are hidden from the public eye so they can be able to demand accountability from the country’s leadership. – We speak truth to power.

Categories

  • banking
  • conflict, war and peace
  • corruption
  • crime, law and justice
  • economic sector
  • economy
  • economy, business and finance
  • financial and business service
  • government
  • In the Press
  • Insight
  • investments
  • law
  • macro economics
  • News
  • Opinion
  • Politics
  • The Cases
  • Uncategorized

Recent Posts

  • Is KZN the factory of hitmen?
  • ANC KwaZulu-Natal displays political intolerance
  • Nepad concerned about South Africa’s energy crisis
  • ANC’s 30-year rule marked by empty promises and rhetoric

Copyright © 2023 - All rights reserved

No Result
View All Result
  • Home
  • The Cases
  • Insight
  • In the Press
  • About
  • Our Team
  • Contact Us

Copyright © 2023 - All rights reserved